Your Guide to Saving the Top Tier of Your Wedding Cake

Will you keep it for your first anniversary?

Eating the top tier of your wedding cake on your first anniversary is an old and classic tradition. But is it safe? Will the dessert even still taste good? Well, that depends. As with many things involving food preservation, it depends on doing everything properly. The easiest route is to have your baker or caterer take care of this for you, but there are various reasons why that might not be a possibility. Should you find it necessary to be the one to wrap up and freeze your cake, read the steps below to make sure it turns out well. 

how to save the top tier of your wedding cake
Photo by Laurie Bailey Photography

First, remove any nonedible decorations. You may also want to take off large sugar flowers or similar adornments, as they might break or poke through the wrapping. Next, you’ll want to put the cake in the refrigerator for at least a couple of hours. Since this will need to happen on the night of the wedding, you may need assistance from a trusted friend or family member. Being in the fridge or a cooler will make the frosting hard enough to be covered in plastic wrap without ruining the aesthetic appeal of the confection. In addition to at least two layers of plastic wrap, adding layers of aluminum foil around the cake will help keep it protected. After all, you don’t want a dried-out dessert for your anniversary! You should even wrap the box in more plastic wrap, just to be extra safe. You may want to consider putting a box of baking soda or something similar in the freezer to absorb smells from other foods so your cake won’t be affected.

Preserving the cake is only the initial step though – you also have to prepare to eat it. The confection needs time to defrost, so the night before your anniversary (or whenever you choose to eat it), put the cake in the refrigerator. You’ll then want it to sit out, unwrapped, at room temperature for about six hours. Then it’s time to enjoy and reflect on one year of married life!

Discover the pros and cons of buttercream frosting vs. fondant and get inspired by 10 of the most popular cake styles

Authored by: Emily Lasnier